On tonight's "Survivor: Redemption Island" Mike Chiesl and David Murphy were both voted out and sent to Redemption Island. The episode began with Rob deciding that Ashley would not make it to the final three if he had anything to do with it, since she didn't tell him about a deal that Ralph offered her. The next day the tribe competed in their first Immunity Challenge, which was a three-part obstacle course that culminated with a block puzzle. The challenge came down to Grant, Mike and David with Grant ultimately taking the win. That night at tribal council the former Ometepe members stuck together and voted out Mike. After tribal, Rob congratulated Phillip on his acting skills and told him he planned on taking him to the final three. The next day the tribe competed in another Immunity Challenge, which consisted of hanging from their legs on a bar over a pool of water. Before the game began, Jeff offered cheeseburgers to anyone who wanted to sit out the challenge. Only Phillip and Steve accepted the offer. The challenge came down to David vs. the women of Ometepe. Once David dropped, the girls agreed to let Andrea win and fell in the water one by one. Later that night at tribal council, the Ometepe six decided to target David and voted him out.
Next week Matt, Mike and David will compete in a Redemption Island duel for the right to stay in the game!