On tonight's "Survivor: Redemption Island" Ralph Kiser and Steve Wright were both voted out and sent to Redemption Island. The episode began with Phillip searching for and eventually finding, his swim trunks that Julie had buried before she was voted out. Later, the tribe made their way to Redemption Island to watch the duel between Matt, Mike and Julie. Matt and Mike easily beat Julie in a game of shuffleboard, sending her home for good and making her the second member of the jury. Back at camp, Rob and Grant decided that Andrea should be the first Ometepe member voted out when the time came, since she expressed regret about voting out Matt. The next day, the tribe competed in the Reward/ Immunity challenge, which was a logrolling competition. After three rounds Grant emerged the winner and was awarded immunity and a giant chocolate cake. Jeff also gave the tribe a mystery package that they couldn't open until tribal council. At camp, Steve made a final plea to the girls to turn on Rob, but they declined the offer and ran right to Rob to tell him what happened. At tribal council, the Ometepe members unsurprisingly voted out Ralph, who was sent to Redemption Island. Jeff then instructed the tribe to open the mystery package, which informed them that they were immediately taking part in their next Immunity challenge. The castaways had to memorize a series of symbols shown by Jeff. Rob remembered the most symbols and was awarded immunity. The Ometepe six then took the opportunity to boot the last remaining Zapatera member and voted out Steve.
Next week Matt, Mike, Ralph and Steve compete in a duel for the right to stay in the game!